Comments on: Jay Severin’s cries for impeachment http://severinwatch.com/2010/04/06/jay-severins-cries-for-impeachment/ Keeping an eye (and ear) on Jay Severin Thu, 09 Sep 2010 13:16:51 +0000 hourly 1 By: DavidFromBrighton http://severinwatch.com/2010/04/06/jay-severins-cries-for-impeachment/comment-page-1/#comment-5257 DavidFromBrighton Wed, 07 Apr 2010 12:01:25 +0000 http://severinwatch.com/2010/04/06/jay-severins-cries-for-impeachment/#comment-5257 I also benefit from discussions with people who have different points of view. But do you think that Jay engages in or promotes "thoughtful, open, honest debate and discussion?" My conclusion is that he does not. If anything, he does a disservice to the positions he espouses, along these lines: "If Jay thinks X because of Y, and if Y is demonstrably wrong, then X is most likely wrong as well." I also benefit from discussions with people who have different points of view. But do you think that Jay engages in or promotes “thoughtful, open, honest debate and discussion?” My conclusion is that he does not. If anything, he does a disservice to the positions he espouses, along these lines: “If Jay thinks X because of Y, and if Y is demonstrably wrong, then X is most likely wrong as well.”

]]> By: Gearman0326 http://severinwatch.com/2010/04/06/jay-severins-cries-for-impeachment/comment-page-1/#comment-5256 Gearman0326 Wed, 07 Apr 2010 04:28:50 +0000 http://severinwatch.com/2010/04/06/jay-severins-cries-for-impeachment/#comment-5256 This is indeed factually correct, He DID in fact open discussion for impeaching Obama- A debate I took part in on his FB page... Open discussion of thoughtful debate... In which we (Those taking part, not Jay) decided that it was an interesting topic for discussion, but questioned if it was meritorious, or in fact, provable in a court of law. He also spent several months, if not a year, openly calling for the impeachment of GW Bush at the beginning of each show- I don't always agree with him, but I find that he always makes me think, and re-evaluate my own position on any given issue/topic. Thoughtful, open, honest, debate and discussion of current events is a good thing- I've found that I learn more from those I disagree with, than from those who think the same. Which is why I listen. Have a great day! This is indeed factually correct, He DID in fact open discussion for impeaching Obama- A debate I took part in on his FB page… Open discussion of thoughtful debate… In which we (Those taking part, not Jay) decided that it was an interesting topic for discussion, but questioned if it was meritorious, or in fact, provable in a court of law.

He also spent several months, if not a year, openly calling for the impeachment of GW Bush at the beginning of each show-

I don’t always agree with him, but I find that he always makes me think, and re-evaluate my own position on any given issue/topic.

Thoughtful, open, honest, debate and discussion of current events is a good thing- I’ve found that I learn more from those I disagree with, than from those who think the same.

Which is why I listen.
Have a great day!

]]>